Comparison
PDF-to-Markdown converters vs a fidelity-checked AI Version
Converters such as Marker, LlamaParse, Unstructured, Docling, Adobe PDF Extract API and Mathpix are good parsers: they turn PDFs into Markdown or JSON for your own pipeline. The Papers starts with conversion and adds what a parser does not state it does: every figure checked against the source, owner confirmation of ambiguities, a permanent canonical link with version history, and analytics on who and which AI read it.
The converters, by their own docs
None of the six states that it verifies extracted figures against the source or hosts a permanent canonical link.
| Tool | What it states | Runs where |
|---|---|---|
| Marker | PDF, images, PPTX, DOCX, XLSX, HTML, EPUB to Markdown, HTML, JSON with coordinates, chunks; optional LLM pass | Locally; hosted API by Datalab |
| LlamaParse | Layout-aware parsing of PDFs, scans, tables and charts to Markdown, text or JSON | API, SDK, web UI |
| Unstructured | Partition, clean, extract and chunk documents for LLMs; canonical JSON schema | Open-source toolkit |
| Docling | PDF, Office, HTML, images; layout, reading order, tables, formulas; Markdown, HTML, lossless JSON | Locally or air-gapped; docling-serve; MCP server |
| Adobe PDF Extract API | Structured JSON with table and figure renditions; Markdown output announced in 2026 | Cloud API |
| Mathpix | PDF to Mathpix Markdown, DOCX, lines JSON | API and SDK |
What a fidelity-checked AI Version adds
| Converter | The Papers | |
|---|---|---|
| Output | Markdown/JSON you store and use | Markdown, JSON and llms.txt published at a permanent URL, plus a page for people |
| Figure checks | Not stated | Every number, currency, date and period matched to the source; no figure that is not in the source |
| Ambiguities | Not stated | Sent to the owner and recorded as owner-confirmed |
| Provenance | Varies (e.g. coordinates in JSON) | Each value references its source page, slide or cell |
| Updates | Re-run the conversion | Version history at the same link |
| Analytics | Not stated | People vs AI readers, by agent and by format |
| Status | Not stated | AI Readiness score; "Fidelity checked" only with zero unresolved critical issues |
When a converter is the better choice
- Bulk archives: you need thousands of files parsed for search or RAG, without per-document review.
- On-premise: documents must never leave your infrastructure (Docling and Marker run locally).
- You are building your own pipeline and only need the text and structure.
When The Papers is the better choice
- A specific document matters (a deck, model, contract, price list) and other people’s AI will read it.
- Figures must be exact, with qualifiers like "forecast" or "unaudited" kept attached.
- You want one canonical link that stays current and shows who read it.
Why parsing is not the same as verifying
A parser’s job is to recover structure: reading order, headings, tables, formulas. Good parsers do this well, and several offer an optional LLM pass to improve it. But a parser does not state that it checks the result against the source, so a merged table cell, a shifted column or a dropped footnote can pass through silently into your pipeline.
Fidelity check asks a different question: does every number, currency, date and period in the output match the source exactly, and is anything present that the source does not contain? In The Papers, failures become issues. Values the source does not settle, such as whether a line is revenue or GMV, go to the owner. The document gets an AI Readiness score and a status, and "Fidelity checked" is only reached with zero unresolved critical issues.
Using them together
- Run a converter such as Docling or Marker over internal archives for search and retrieval, where scale matters more than per-document review.
- Pick the documents that leave the company and carry figures people rely on: investor deck, financial model, price list, policy, contract summary.
- Publish those in The Papers: fidelity-checked Markdown and JSON at a permanent link, plus an llms.txt index for the Data Room.
- Point internal agents at the published Markdown or JSON when they need the version of record, and keep the converter output for broad recall.
By role
| Role | Typical need | Better fit |
|---|---|---|
| ML or data engineer | Parse thousands of PDFs into chunks for RAG | A converter |
| Security-sensitive team | Nothing may leave the network | A converter that runs locally or air-gapped |
| Finance lead | A model and accounts that outside AI must read exactly | The Papers |
| Founder or IR | A deck and update investors screen with AI | The Papers |
| Docs or support team | Spec sheets and policies that bots and assistants quote | The Papers, with version history at one link |
FAQ
- Is The Papers a PDF-to-Markdown converter?
- No. Conversion is only the first step; fidelity check against the source and the published canonical version are the product.
- Can I use a converter and The Papers together?
- Yes. Use a converter for bulk archives and internal pipelines, and The Papers for the documents others will read with AI.
- Does fidelity check mean the numbers are correct?
- It means faithful to the source. The Papers does not certify that the source content is true.
- Which inputs does The Papers accept?
- PDF (with OCR fallback for scanned pages), PowerPoint including native charts and speaker notes, Excel including formulas and named ranges, Word and Markdown.
- What does the JSON contain?
- Schema papers-document/1.1: blocks, metrics with period, currency and classification, qualifiers, claims and page provenance.
- Is The Papers suited to bulk conversion?
- No. Each document is checked against the source individually, so for archives without per-document review a converter is the better tool.